Figure 2. Wheelchair Work Values for Straight Propulsion

The bar graph shows work values (vertical axis) for various surfaces (horizontal axis), compared to work to wheel on ramps of various slopes. Work, in Newton-meters, for ramps is: 35.5 for 3%, 44.5 for 4%, 53.5 for 5%, and 71.6 for 7%.

Work for various surfaces is:

SURFACE WORK
C1P0 20.4
C1P1 23.5
C2P1 32.5
C2P2 36.6
C2P4 39.7
C3P0 43.2
C3P3 50.5
RDOL 21.9
ASPP 13.8
RDMX 27.6
PAFN 21.6
DIRP 34.4
CPBR 41.7
EWFK 56.7
EWFJ 58.7
SAND Unable to test

Figure 3. Wheelchair Work Values for Turning

The bar graph shows work values (vertical axis) for various surfaces (horizontal axis), compared to work to turn on ramps of various slopes. Work, in Newton-meters, for ramps is: 26.2 for 3%, 33.1 for 4%, 40.0 for 5%, and 53.7 for 7%.

SURFACE WORK
C1P0 17.2
C1P1 21.3
C2P1 26.8
C2P2 31.1
C2P4 29.3
C3P0 31.3
C3P3 38.2
RDOL 17.2
ASPP 23.1
RDMX 16.7
PAFN 22.2
DIRP 29.8
CPBR 38.6
EWFK 56.0
EWFJ 52.0
SAND Unable to test

Figure 4. Rotational Penetrometer Firmness Measurements

The bar graph shows displacement in inches, as measured by the rotational penetrometer, on the vertical axis for various surfaces (horizontal axis).  Suggested criteria for "firm" is a displacement depth of less than 0.3 inches; "moderately firm" is 0.3 to 0.5 inches; "not firm" is greater than 0.5 inches 

SURFACE DISPLACEMENT
C1P0 0.22
C1P1 0.26
C2P1 0.26
C2P2 0.40
C2P4 0.31
C3P0 0.32
C3P3 0.43
RDOL 0.14
ASPP 0.17
RDMX 0.16
PAFN 0.15
DIRP 0.22
CPBR 0.28
EWFK 0.31
EWFJ 0.34
SAND greater than 0.6

Figure 5. Rotational Penetrometer Stability Measurements

The bar graph shows measurement with the penetrometer of stability as displacement in inches on the vertical axis, for various materials. Suggested criteria for "stable" is a displacement depth of less than 0.5 inch; "moderately stable is 0.5 to 1.0 inch; "not stable is greater than 1.0 inch.

SURFACE DISPLACEMENT
C1P0 0.26
C1P1 0.34
C2P1 0.36
C2P2 0.46
C2P4 0.39
C3P0 0.41
C3P3 0.55
RDOL 0.15
ASPP 0.24
RDMX 0.20
PAFN 0.21
DIRP 0.42
CPBR 0.91
EWFK 0.83
EWFJ 1.01
SAND greater than 1.5

Figure 6. Rotational Penetrometer Firmness Measurement for Dry and Wet Surfaces

The bar graph shows displacement in inches, as measured by the rotational penetrometer, on the vertical axis for various wet and dry surfaces (horizontal axis).  Suggested criteria for "firm" is a displacement depth of less than 0.3 inches; "moderately firm" is 0.3 to 0.5 inches; "not firm" is greater than 0.5 inches

SURFACE DISPLACEMENT - DRY DISPLACEMENT - WET
RDOL 0.14 0.19
ASPP 0.17 0.21
RDMX 0.16 0.22
PAFN 0.15 0.23
DIRP 0.22 0.24
CPBR 0.28 0.41
EWFK 0.31 0.44
EWFJ 0.34 0.47
SAND greater than 0.6 0.48

Figure 7. Rotational Penetrometer Stability Measurements for Wet and Dry Surfaces

The bar graph shows measurement with the penetrometer of stability as displacement in inches on the vertical axis, for various wet and dry materials. Suggested criteria for "stable" is a displacement depth of less than 0.5 inch; "moderately stable is 0.5 to 1.0 inch; "not stable is greater than 1.0 inch.

SURFACE DISPLACEMENT - DRY DISPLACEMENT - WET
RDOL 0.15 0.26
ASPP 0.24 0.23
RDMX 0.20 0.47
PAFN 0.21 1.22
DIRP 0.42 0.57
CPBR 0.91 0.78
EWFK 0.83 0.90
EWFJ 1.01 1.37
SAND greater than 1.5 greater than 1.5

Figure 8. Average Energy Consumption for All Subjects Combined

The bar graph plots energy consumption, on the vertical avis, as average milliliters of oxygen used per kilogram per meter for various surfaces, and notes the number of subjects who completed the test (total subjects = 39). The actual oxygen consumption is not given, but can be approximated from the graph.

SURFACE OXYGEN SUBJECTS
ADAG 0.12 36
RDOL 0.11 36
ASPP 0.13 38
RDMX 0.13 35
PAFN 0.13 35
DIRP 0.15 37
CPBR 0.17 33
EWFK 0.18 35
EWFJ 0.2 35
SAND 0.24 27

Figure 9. Average Energy Consumption for Subjects with No Disability (NoDis), Ambulatory with Limited Mobility (AwLM), and Ambulatory with Assistive Devices (AwAD)

The bar graph plots energy consumption, on the vertical axis, as average milliliters of oxygen used per kilogram per meter for various surfaces, for each group. The actual oxygen consumption is not given, but can be approximated from the graph.

SURFACE NoDIS AwLM AwAD
ADAG 0.1 0.14 0.13
RDOL 0.08 0.15 0.15
ASPP 0.1 0.12 0.18
RDMX 0.1 0.15 0.17
PAFN 0.08 0.15 0.18
DIRP 0.12 0.15 0.18
CPBR 0.1 0.16 0.21
EWFK 0.1 0.14 0.22
EWFJ 0.1 0.17 0.22
SAND 0.17 0.13 0.25

Figure !0. Average Energy Consumption for Subjects with No Disability (NoDis) and Manual Wheelchair Users (Wc)

The bar graph plots energy consumption, on the vertical axis, as average milliliters of oxygen used per kilogram per meter for various surfaces, for each group. The actual oxygen consumption is not given, but can be approximated from the graph.

SURFACE NoDis Wc
ADAG 0.1 0.14
RDOL 0.08 0.1
ASPP 0.1 0.12
RDMX 0.1 0.12
PAFN 0.08 0.1
DIRP 0.12 0.2
CPBR 0.09 0.27
EWFK 0.1 0.31
EWFJ 0.11 0.37
SAND 0.16 greater than 0.4